AVOIDING WRITING PROBLEMS
A pronoun should never refer to more than one noun phrase.
Whenever a pronoun may refer to more than one noun phrase, your reader will be
confused.
What is confusing about this sentence?
The passengers waited all night
while the airplane mechanic and her assistant worked to repair the engine. By
morning, they were exhausted.
The reader cannot tell whether
‘they’ refer to ‘passengers’ or ‘airplane’ ‘mechanic’ and ‘her assistant.’ The
use of the pronoun ‘they’ is said to be ambiguous.
What is confusing about these sentences?
The cat knocked over the table
with the lamp on it, and it broke.
Ned was riding his horse over the
bridge when it fell into the water with him on it.
There are too many books on those
shelves. If you are not careful, they’ll fall.
Watch out for ambiguous pronouns!
Any time you use a pronoun to replace a noun
phrase, make sure the pronoun refers only to that noun phrase and not to some
other one as well. An experienced writer will check every pronoun to be sure
that it refers to just a single noun phrase.
Are there any ambiguous pronouns
in these sentences? Which pronouns are they? How would you rewrite these
sentences so that they are no longer ambiguous?
[1] There were many people in the
restaurant tonight and the waiters worked very hard. They were tired when they
got home.
[2]I got a letter today from an
old friend, and I was pleased to hear from her.
[3] There were so many people
that it was hard to move and so many different refreshments that I couldn’t
choose. They were all gone by morning, though.
[4] Judy and Marcia, who were
running for the student council, went to watch the school basketball team. They
won that night.
[5] While Fred was walking his
dog, he broke his leg.
Always be sure to check your
writing for ambiguous pronouns. They can appear when you are least expecting
it. Sometimes thoughts that are clear to the writer’s mind are not so clear on
paper.
Comments
Post a Comment